Should fans expect a very pleasant surprise for the prequel series in the new year?
With 2026 just around the corner, it feels like the right moment to look back and admit something most of us can agree on: 2025 was an absolutely incredible year to be a Dexter fan. Having two different Dexter shows airing new episodes already felt like a gift, but what actually stood out was how the main storyline continued in Dexter: Resurrection starring Michael C. Hall.
The show has been widely praised and now stands as a strong pillar that can easily carry Dexter forward for years to come. And when we talk about “more,” it’s not only about future seasons of Resurrection, but also about a broader revival of the Dexter universe itself. This feels especially important given that, since Paramount’s merger with Skydance, the franchise has unfortunately gone through a noticeable downsizing.
One of the biggest disappointments came when Dexter: Original Sin was left un-renewed after its first season. Despite a successful run, months of fan backlash, and a petition with more than 106,000 signatures, the network has so far stood by its decision.
What many fans might not actually know though, is that shortly after the cancellation was announced, the Dexter: Original Sin set at CBS Radford Studios was completely torn down. This included the amazingly recreated Miami Metro P.D. set, which looked almost identical to the original series aside from a few necessary updates, as well as the Morgan family home.
This happened in fall, at a time when fan reactions to the cancellation were still strong. At first glance, this kind of development might seem final and discouraging, but it doesn’t necessarily mean the door is closed forever. In short, the decision is not as irreversible as it may appear, and a second season of Dexter: Original Sin can still happen.
There are a few factors that could genuinely make a difference. One of the most important is keeping the conversation alive. As director Marcos Siega recently reminded fans, the prequel shouldn’t be allowed to fade away quietly. Continued discussion online, constant mentions on social media, and highlihgting the show’s potential, such as introducing a younger version of characters like James Doakes, all actually help keep the project visible. Strong buzz does matter, and networks do notice when fans refuse to move on.
Viewership is another thing that is significant. Rewatching Dexter: Original Sin on Paramount+ or recommending it to new viewers can slowly but meaningfully boost its numbers. Streaming metrics play a big role in renewal decisions, and increased engagement over time has actually reversed cancellations before. Then htere’s the larger industry context, particularly Paramount’s ongoing interest in acquiring Warner Bros.
Most of you might already be aware of the ongoing attempts by both Netflix and Paramount to buy Warner Bros. While the deal is still unresolved, Netflix appears to be the most likely winner. From a Dexter fan’s perspective, it is actually important that Paramount doesn’t win that bid. A massive acquisition like Warner Bros. would likely shift focus toward library expansion rather than...nurturing existing franchises, and Dexter could easily be sidelined. As strange as it sounds, Netflix acquiring Warner Bros. may be the least damaging outcome for the future of Dexter.
If Dexter: Original Sin does eventually get renewed, the timing of new episodes is another big question. Even if Paramount were to change course in 2026 and officially greenlight Season 2, we shouldn’t actually expect new episodes to air that same year. There simply wouldn’t be enough time not only to rebuild sets, but also restart production, and complete post-production. The fall of 2026 is already effectively reserved for Dexter: Resurrection Season 2, which will also coincide with the original series’ 20th anniversary. If the prequel returns, the most realistic scenario is a premiere sometime in 2027.
For now, we are in a strange but also hopeful place. The franchise is maybe at its peak of popularity, even if not every project has survived. And as history has shown when it comes to Dexter, things have a way of coming back from the dead!