The renewal is taking longer than anyone expected—could this delay signal something major?
It’s now been over three weeks since the finale of Dexter: Resurrection dropped, yet Paramount+ and Showtime remain completely silent on the topic almost every fan is desperate to hear about: a second season renewal. With such a successful return for one of television’s most iconic antiheroes, the question on everyone’s mind is simple: why the delay?
Dexter: Resurrection Was a Hit—So What’s the Hold Up?
There’s no denying it: Dexter: Resurrection has been a massive success for Paramount+. Not only did the series bring Michael C. Hall’s beloved character back in a way that subverted expectations and earned near-unanimous praise from critics and fans alike, but its streaming numbers were strong from premiere to finale. For a franchise that stumbled in the past, this revival was the home run fans had been waiting for.
Before the recent merger between Paramount and Skydance, the previous leadership made it clear that Dexter was a top priority, with plans to turn the property into a full-blown franchise. Those ambitions were obvious with the announcement of multiple spinoffs, including Dexter: Original Sin.
But everything changed after the merger. New leadership brought a new strategy, and one of the first casualties was the cancellation of Original Sin. Although insiders suggested that shelving the prequel might allow the creative team to focus entirely on Dexter: Resurrection, that theory has never been confirmed.
A Strange Delay Compared to Other Paramount Renewals
What makes the wait even more puzzling is that Paramount has shown no hesitation in renewing other shows. Just days ago, the company gave Tulsa King—starring Sylvester Stallone—a fourth-season renewal, even though its upcoming season didn't even premiere at that point. Meanwhile, fans of Dexter are still refreshing their feeds in frustration, wondering why a proven hit like Resurrection hasn’t received the same treatment.
Adding to the intrigue is a potential Warner Bros. acquisition. On September 11, reports surfaced that Paramount is actively pursuing a bid to acquire Warner Bros. While such a major corporate move could certainly cause delays in decision-making, the speedy Tulsa King renewal suggests this might not be the full story.
Possible Reasons for the Delay
So why hasn’t Dexter: Resurrection been renewed yet? Here are the most likely explanations:
1. A Change of Heart About Dexter: Original Sin
Despite the showrunner’s recent comments downplaying this possibility, there’s growing speculation that Paramount may be reconsidering its decision to cancel Dexter: Original Sin. A massive fan petition with over 102,000 verified signatures is still gaining traction. It’s possible the company is planning a double announcement, renewing both Resurrection and Original Sin in a single press release to create maximum buzz.
2. Waiting for the Writers’ Room to Open
According to Clyde Phillips, the Season 2 writers’ room for Dexter: Resurrection is set to open on Monday, October 6th. Paramount might be holding off on any official announcement until that date to tie the renewal to a milestone that excites fans and signals creative momentum.
3. Shifting Priorities After the Merger
The Paramount-Skydance merger has led to a major reshuffling of priorities. Public relations and content strategy may have temporarily taken a backseat while the company focuses on internal restructuring, resulting in delayed renewal announcements across certain properties, including Dexter.
Should Fans Worry About Dexter: Resurrection’s Future?
In short, no. It would be almost unthinkable for Paramount to cancel the only active series in the Dexter universe, especially after such a critically acclaimed and commercially successful season. In a recent interview, showrunner Clyde Phillips even spoke about Season 2 as if it were already a done deal, offering reassurance that the creative team is moving forward despite the lack of an official greenlight.
Fans should take comfort in that confidence. While the silence is frustrating, all signs point to Dexter: Resurrection returning for another thrilling season. The wait, it seems, is more about corporate timing than any real danger to the series itself.
The question isn’t if Dexter: Resurrection will be renewed, it’s when. Whether Paramount+ is planning a surprise announcement tied to the writers’ room opening, a dual renewal with Original Sin, or simply waiting for the right moment to dominate headlines, one thing is certain: Dexter isn’t done yet.