More than 100,000 fans have voiced their support for bringing the Dexter prequel back.
On August 22, 2025, the Dexter fandom was rocked by shocking news: Dexter: Original Sin was abruptly cancelled (or more accurately, un-renewed). This decision came just months after a Season 2 renewal was announced in April, leaving both fans and even the show’s cast blindsided. According to sources, actors found out about the cancellation through the media, learning of the show’s fate at the same time as viewers.
The cancellation was widely criticized as a major misstep by Paramount’s new leadership following the company’s merger with Skydance. Fans immediately mobilized, launching multiple “Save Dexter: Original Sin” petitions urging Paramount to reconsider the decision and reverse course.
Fan Power in Action: Petition Hits 100,000 Signatures
Exactly one month later, on September 22, 2025, the main petition to save Dexter: Original Sin reached a huge milestone: 100,000 verified signatures. For a prequel series—especially one tied to a franchise already running a new sequel (Dexter: Resurrection)—those numbers are nothing short of extraordinary.
If Original Sin were truly a “bad show,” fans argue, it would never have inspired this level of dedication, particularly when they already have new Dexter content to watch. The sheer volume of support proves that the prequel struck a nerve with viewers and deserves a second chance.
Could Paramount Reverse the Cancellation?
Television history shows that fan campaigns can work. Beloved shows like Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Lucifer, The Expanse, and Timeless were all rescued after cancellation—either by their original networks or through pickups by other platforms.
However, not every campaign ends in victory. Series such as The OA, Hannibal, and Firefly remain cautionary tales of fan passion that couldn’t overcome network decisions. The fate of Dexter: Original Sin now hangs in a similar balance.
Clyde Phillips Offers a Sobering Update
His comments stung even more after he revealed tantalizing details about the scrapped Season 2 storyline, which would have focused heavily on Brian Moser and introduced younger versions of James Doakes and Tom Matthews.
The Waiting Game: What’s Next for Dexter Fans
Despite the uncertainty, the petition continues to climb beyond 100,000 signatures, proving fan momentum is far from slowing down. Many are also anxiously awaiting news on Dexter: Resurrection, the sequel series starring Michael C. Hall, which is widely expected to receive a Season 2 renewal.
Producers and actors have hinted that Resurrection is designed for multiple seasons, and a writers’ room is reportedly set to open on October 6th. But Paramount has yet to make an official announcement, leaving fans uneasy that Resurrection could face a fate similar to Original Sin.
A Best-Case Scenario Fans Are Hoping For
The dream outcome for Dexter devotees? A double renewal—one that revives Dexter: Original Sin and greenlights Dexter: Resurrection Season 2 at the same time. While that may sound like wishful thinking, it’s not impossible. Television history is full of surprises, and all it takes is a change of heart from Paramount to bring the prequel back from the dead.