Even though all signs point to an official renewal, many fans remain unconvinced.
With Season 1 of Dexter: Resurrection officially wrapped, speculation is running wild about the future of the show. The exciting season finale made it crystal clear that Dexter Morgan’s story isn’t over, leaving fans hungry for more. But alongside the excitement, there’s also a lingering doubt: Will Paramount actually renew the series for a second season?
On the surface, everything looks promising. Dexter: Resurrection has been a hit with both critics and fans, delivering strong viewership numbers and very positive buzz across social media. Even the writers themselves have hinted at long-term plans for the story. Yet, scrolling through Dexter Daily’s social channels, it’s impossible to ignore the skepticism in the replies whenever Season 2 speculation comes up.
So why the hesitation? The answer lies in one painful word for fans: cancellation.
The Shadow of Dexter: Original Sin
2024 was a groundbreaking year for the Dexter franchise. Not only did Showtime and Paramount+ expand the universe with the prequel series Dexter: Original Sin, starring Patrick Gibson as young Dexter Morgan, but they also announced the sequel series Dexter: Resurrection, continuing the story of Dexter: New Blood.
Momentum was strong, and fans were excited for more spinoffs to come. That is, until 2025 brought a major shakeup. Following Paramount’s merger with Skydance, the new leadership axed Original Sin—a series that had already been unofficially renewed. This decision sent shockwaves through the fandom.
Many fans now worry that if a successful and promising series like Original Sin could be scrapped so suddenly, Resurrection might suffer the same fate. After all, the new Paramount seems to be shifting priorities, with blockbuster deals like a new Call of Duty movie taking the spotlight.
Can Fans Trust Paramount With Dexter’s Future?
When reports surfaced that the Dexter: Resurrection writers’ room would soon open for Season 2, reactions were mixed. On one hand, fans celebrated the news; on the other, many questioned whether Paramount would simply pull the plug later, as they did with Original Sin.
Some longtime viewers feel that what was once one of Showtime and Paramount’s crown jewels is no longer treated as a top priority. That fear has fueled petitions, campaigns, and endless debates online.
Why Resurrection Is Safer Than Original Sin
Here’s the good news: Like we said in a previous article, and despite the worries that followed even after that, it’s very unlikely that Dexter: Resurrection will share the same fate as its prequel. The sequel is a bigger franchise asset, fueled by Michael C. Hall’s iconic portrayal of Dexter Morgan and a passionate fanbase that has already proven its dedication. While Paramount’s new leadership hasn’t officially announced a renewal yet, all signs point to the show being too valuable to discard.
As for Dexter: Original Sin, cancellation might not be the final word. Multiple reports suggest the series was cut not because of poor performance, but because the company wanted to concentrate resources on a single Dexter show. With enough fan support, there’s still a real possibility the prequel could return down the line.
The Petition to Save Dexter: Original Sin
Fans are making their voices heard. In just 15 days, 80,000 signatures have poured in demanding Paramount reverse its decision on Original Sin. That leaves only 20,000 more before hitting the powerful milestone of 100,000 signatures.
In the TV industry, it’s rare for canceled shows to generate that kind of response. When they do, networks often have no choice but to take notice. If the petition succeeds, Original Sin may yet rise again.
👉 [Sign the petition to save Dexter: Original Sin here.]
Final Thoughts
The future of Dexter as a franchise may feel uncertain right now, but one thing is undeniable: the fanbase is stronger than ever. With its compelling writing, outstanding performances, and critical acclaim, Dexter: Resurrection is a huge asset for Paramount. Pair that with a petition that’s rapidly approaching 100K signatures, and the message is clear: Dexter still matters.
Whether it’s a guaranteed Resurrection Season 2 or a potential... resurrection of Original Sin, the franchise isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. The fans have spoken, and history has shown that when passion meets persistence, networks listen.
So should fans doubt? Perhaps a little. But should they hope? Absolutely.