It's official: Scott Buck makes a surprising and triumphant return to the Dexter franchise!
Dexter: Resurrection exploded onto the scene with a back-to-back premiere that had fans buzzing across the internet. The excitement was palpable — and rightly so. While Episode 1, “A Beating Heart…” (written by the powerhouse duo Clyde Phillips and Scott Reynolds), captivated viewers with its cameo-packed storyline, Episode 2 also made waves... for a very unexpected reason.
Who Wrote Episode 2, “Camera Shy”?
In a twist that surprised many — especially die-hard fans who actually pay attention to writing credits — Episode 2, “Camera Shy,” was penned by none other than Scott Buck.
Yes, that Scott Buck — the man behind much of the second half of the original Dexter series. Buck served as showrunner and head of the writing team for Seasons 6, 7, and 8. His return to the franchise after over a decade is both surprising and nostalgic, calling back memories of the early 2010s era of Dexter.
A Closely Guarded Secret
Showtime and the Dexter: Resurrection team kept Scott Buck’s return tightly under wraps until the episode dropped on Paramount+. Interestingly, even trusted online sources had listed the wrong writers for Episode 2 — claiming it was the work of Dexter: Original Sin scribes Tanner Bean and Katrina Mathewson.
So, why the secrecy? That question opens the door to a more complex discussion.
The Scott Buck Controversy
Scott Buck has long been a polarizing figure among Dexter fans. While he undoubtedly penned some of the series' most compelling episodes, his run as showrunner drew heavy criticism. Fans were particularly divided over plot developments in Season 6 and beyond — including Debra Morgan's controversial feelings for Dexter, the introduction of Hannah McKay, the Evelyn Vogel storyline, and of course, the original series finale, which remains one of television’s most debated endings.
That said, credit must be given where it's due. Buck joined Dexter as a co-executive producer and writer in Season 2, delivering unforgettable episodes that stand as exceptional television. Who could forget the brilliance of "Morning Comes" or "Left Turn Ahead"? Truly remarkable work.
All Dexter Episodes Written by Scott Buck:
Season 2
- “See-Through” (Ep 4)
- “Morning Comes” (Ep 8)
- “Left Turn Ahead” (Ep 11, co-written with Tim Schlattmann)
Season 3
- “The Lion Sleeps Tonight” (Ep 3)
- “The Damage a Man Can Do” (Ep 8)
- “Do You Take Dexter Morgan?” (Ep 12)
Season 4
- “Blinded by the Light” (Ep 3)
- “Slack Tide” (Ep 7)
- “Hello, Dexter Morgan” (Ep 11, co-written with Lauren Gussis)
Season 5
- “My Bad” (Ep 1)
- “Circle Us” (Ep 7)
- “Hop a Freighter” (Ep 11, co-written teleplay)
Season 6
- “Those Kinds of Things” (Ep 1)
- “This Is the Way the World Ends” (Ep 2, co-written with Wendy West)
Season 7
- “Are You…?” (Ep 1)
- “Surprise, Motherfucker!” (Ep 12, co-written with Tim Schlattmann)
Season 8
- “A Beautiful Day” (Ep 1)
- “Remember the Monsters?” (Ep 12 - series finale)
While some of Buck's decisions as showrunner sparked intense debate, his talent as a writer has always been undeniable.
Return After a Long Hiatus
Scott Buck’s return to Dexter comes after a significant hiatus from writing. His last major credit was as showrunner for Marvel’s Inhumans on ABC — a short-lived series that ended after just one season.
But with Dexter: Resurrection, Buck appears ready for a second chance — not as a showrunner this time, but back in the writer’s chair where he arguably does his best work.
How Was Buck’s Episode Received?
Episode 2, “Camera Shy,” has been met with overwhelmingly positive reactions. Fans appreciated the smart, punchy dialogue, a return to dark humor, and the classic Dexter voiceover wit that defined the show's early seasons. And, in true Dexter: New Blood fashion, Buck’s name wasn’t revealed until the end credits, making the revelation all the more surprising.
Many fans watching had no idea that the man behind some of their most controversial — and memorable — Dexter moments was behind this new episode.
A Redemption Arc in the Making?
Whether you're a longtime fan or new to the franchise, one thing’s clear: Scott Buck’s return has sparked conversation and reflection. While his showrunning years were divisive, his writing resume speaks for itself.
His work on Camera Shy has reminded viewers of the unique tone and tension that only a seasoned Dexter writer can deliver.
Welcome back to the world of Dexter, Scott Buck — it’s good to have you again.