Across the internet, fans are expressing anger and frustration over the cancellation of the prequel.
As Dexter: Resurrection reaches Episode 8 and fans continue to celebrate the revival of the franchise, yesterday’s news delivered a shocking blow to the Dexter community: Dexter: Original Sin — the prequel series set in 1991 Miami — has officially been cancelled after one season.
The cancellation is especially surprising because the series had already been renewed for a second season just five months ago. At the time, everything seemed secure, and fans were eagerly waiting for production to begin. But everything changed rapidly after Paramount+ completed its merger with Skydance on August 8, bringing in new leadership that quickly made the controversial decision to axe the show.
Why the Cancellation Hurts So Much
For longtime Dexter fans, this decision feels both disappointing and unfair. Social media has been flooded with outrage and sadness, proving that Dexter: Original Sin wasn’t “just another show.” It was shaping up to be a compelling and authentic addition to the Dexter universe.
The prequel promised answers to questions fans have had for years — how James Doakes first crossed paths with Dexter and began to suspect him, how Dexter acquired the condo we know from the original series, and more hidden details about his early years. Losing that potential storyline has left fans feeling robbed of an exciting chapter of the Dexter mythos.
A Cast Fans Were Ready to Embrace
The casting process for Dexter: Original Sin was extensive, with the production team carefully selecting actors to play younger versions of beloved characters. Each actor studied the mannerisms, speech patterns, and personalities of the original cast to deliver authentic performances.
This dedication paid off, and fans were already impressed by the potential after early announcements. With a second season greenlit, actors continued their work to deepen these portrayals. Now, all of that preparation feels wasted — unless the decision is reversed.
Fans Are Fighting Back — Petitions to Save Dexter: Original Sin
But Dexter fans aren’t giving up without a fight. In true passionate fashion, multiple petitions have already been launched on Change.org, calling on Paramount+ to reconsider its decision. Despite being brand new, these petitions are already gaining thousands of signatures, showing just how much support exists for the series.
The message is clear: fans loved Dexter: Original Sin and want it back. If there’s any chance of overturning this decision, it lies in the power of the Dexter community to speak out, sign petitions, and make their voices heard.
How You Can Help Save Dexter: Original Sin
Every single signature matters. If you want to see the story of young Dexter Morgan continue, you can join the movement today:
UPDATE: We’ve just created another petition. For greater impact, you can sign both.
👉 Click here to sign Dexter Daily's petition to save Dexter: Original Sin.
👉 Click here to sign the other petition to save Dexter: Original Sin.
The Dexter fandom has proven its strength time and time again. Let’s show Paramount+ that this decision was a mistake — and that Dexter: Original Sin deserves a second chance.
Save Dexter: Original Sin!