Five clues that this surviving character is the prime candidate to return in the Dexter sequel.
Dexter: Resurrection is just around the corner, and the promotional machine is in full swing. From teaser trailers to billboards, Showtime is pulling out all the stops to build anticipation for Dexter Morgan’s highly anticipated return—this time, navigating a new life (and likely, new kills) in the bustling streets of New York City.
While several beloved characters have already been confirmed to reprise their roles—either as regulars or in surprise cameos—some returns remain under wraps. One of the most intriguing possibilities? The return of Desmond Harrington as Detective Joseph “Joey” Quinn.
Although not officially announced, compelling fan theories—and a trail of subtle hints—strongly suggest that Quinn may have already filmed scenes for Dexter: Resurrection.
Is Joey Quinn Returning in Dexter: Resurrection? 5 Major Clues Point to Yes
Here's a breakdown of the biggest clues pointing to his secret comeback.
1. His Deep Connection with Angel Batista
Quinn’s dynamic with Angel Batista was one of the most enduring friendships throughout Dexter's original run. Though they had their share of ups and downs—especially when Quinn started dating Batista’s sister Jamie in Season 8—the two shared a genuine bond.
With Batista now confirmed as a series regular in Dexter: Resurrection, it’s not far-fetched to think he’s still in touch with Quinn. Some fans speculate that Batista may have temporarily handed off his duties as Miami Metro Captain to Quinn while heading to New York to investigate Dexter’s mysterious reappearance. If Batista is in NYC on official business, could Quinn be aiding him behind the scenes—or even joining him in person?
2. He Might Know Dexter’s Secret
One of the most compelling reasons for Quinn’s return lies in his unresolved suspicions about Dexter. In Season 5, following Rita’s tragic death, Quinn began digging into Dexter’s life—convinced something was off. But after Dexter helped him cover up his potential involvement in Stan Liddy’s murder, Quinn backed off.
Many fans believe Quinn knows the truth about Dexter’s double life but chose to look the other way. That kind of narrative thread is ripe for exploration in Resurrection, especially with Batista now actively searching for answers about Dexter’s past. How would Quinn handle Batista’s investigation? Would he finally confess what he knows—or continue to protect Dexter?
3. Desmond Harrington’s Telling Interview Reaction
Back in February, Desmond Harrington appeared as a guest on the Dexter: Original Sin aftershow hosted by Jamie Chung. During the discussion, Chung asked if Quinn might return in Dexter: Resurrection.
Harrington’s response? “I will not say a f*cking word. I don’t know,” he said with a smirk.
That smirk didn’t go unnoticed. Jamie quickly added, “Oh, look at that smirk. I know how to read people.”
It was a moment that sent the fandom buzzing. While not confirmation, his coy reaction strongly hinted at a surprise return—and many fans took it as a quiet nod to something already in the works.
4. He’s a Native New Yorker—And That Matters
Here’s a practical angle that makes Quinn’s return even more likely: Desmond Harrington is a New Yorker. And with Dexter: Resurrection filming in New York City from January 9 through June 17, his local presence could have made it easy for the showrunners to bring him back discreetly.
Actors like Uma Thurman and Peter Dinklage, also native New Yorkers, have spoken about how filming Dexter: Resurrection in their hometown is a major advantage. For Harrington, jumping into a surprise cameo—or even a full scene—would require minimal scheduling hassle, making his involvement all the more feasible.
5. Deleted Instagram Posts Stir Suspicion
Fans have noticed that Harrington occasionally shares Dexter-related content on Instagram—only to delete it shortly after. While he’s known for deleting posts in general, some fans believe this is his subtle way of teasing a secret return without getting into trouble with the studio.
Though speculative, it fits the larger pattern of secrecy surrounding many aspects of Dexter: Resurrection. The show has made it clear that surprises are in store—and this could be one of them.
Final Thoughts: Is Quinn’s Return Inevitable?
Whether he's involved in a Miami club scene or appears alongside Batista in New York, all signs suggest that Joey Quinn's return isn't just possible—it’s likely. His unfinished storyline, lingering suspicions about Dexter, and close bond with Batista all provide a perfect setup for his reappearance.
While we wait for official confirmation, the clues are stacking up. And when it comes to Dexter, surprises are always just one kill room away.
Stay tuned to DexterDaily.com for the latest news, and deep dives into everything Dexter: Resurrection. Don’t forget to follow us on social media and sign up for alerts so you don’t miss a single update.