Dexter: Resurrection Season 2 ‘Live Free and Die’ Review: Episode 3 Finally Lives Up to Season 1

Our full review of Dexter: Resurrection Season 2 Episode 3, “Live Free and Die,” is here, complete with our verdict and a score out of 10.


The following contains MASSIVE SPOILERS for the third episode of season two of ‘Dexter: Resurrection’ titled ‘Live Free and Die’ - Proceed with caution.

Episode three hits the ground running and (literally) rewinds the clock to give us a front row seat to the Five Borough Killer’s (FBK) second murder. This event finally puts Dexter in the direct path of the season’s “big bad” but it ends up moving the season forward in some truly unexpected ways.

It’s an episode that brilliantly juggles the multi-faceted storyline without interfering with the elements that have kept Dexter fun and relevant for 20 years.

In fact, despite all the moving parts, the writers found a way of putting a new twist on the good ol’ fashioned “kill-of-the-week” formula that fans crave. If you ask me, it’s an episode with a little bit of everything and perhaps even the first episode of the season that truly lives up to the extremely high-bar set in season one. Read on for my full review and analysis.

EPISODE RECAP

Before we jump into the analysis, let’s take a look at the most important story developments in the episode:

  • Dexter gives chase but eventually loses track of FBK when he escapes via a fire escape.
  • Harrison works with Dexter to start a sketch of FBK but is unable to share it with the department out of concern for putting Dexter back on Claudette’s radar.
  • Claudette is taunted by Don Framt outside of the FBK crime scene leading her to divulge the reason behind her infatuation with the song ‘Stayin Alive.’
  • Quinn calls Dexter to give him an update on his hunt for Prater where he reveals that he has caught wind of Charley’s rental of the NYC brownstone.
  • Dexter and Charley move on the Sleepy-Eyes Stranger but have to change their plan when he reveals that he brought a live victim with him to NYC as a share for Prater.
  • Dexter and Charley work together to trick the Sleepy-Eyed Stranger into revealing where he stashed his future victim before turning the tables and getting him on Dexter’s table.
  • Dexter gets his kill and then tips Quinn off to the location of Ray’s victim in a nearby parking garage; Allowing Quinn to swoop in and save the day.
  • Dexter has a heart-to-heart with Harrison who is feeling frustrated by the limitations of police work. He reveals some important truths about Harry’s choice to train Dexter as a killer and how it relates to the concept of justice.

"Hello, Two-Borough Killer"

There’s a lot happening at the top of the episode. FBK makes his move on an unsuspecting maintenance worker but inadvertently puts himself in Dexter’s crosshairs as chaos unfolds in the streets.

It’s a fun (and nostalgic) game of cat-and-mouse that ultimately ends with FBK’s escape. However, if you ask me, the scene’s true purpose is to trickle out some important clues that I suspect will make a lot more sense as the season progresses.

In the chaos, FBK drops his smart-glasses in a stairwell and then races to grab them before Dexter reaches him. This moment not only speaks to FBK’s priorities and his willingness to take risks, it also gives Dexter a perfect view of the wedding band that he wears.

When paired with several other carefully curated close-ups of FBK in his home later in the episode, it certainly starts to paint an interesting picture.


Is FBK just an attention-seeking psychopath or is there something far more personal at play? Could his “Nobody Cares” tagline be referring to the broad, self-serving nature of everyday people who are going about their lives? Or are his actions in direct response to a personal loss or tragedy that he feels went unnoticed by the people around him?

Either way, I think a deeper mystery surrounding this villain is starting to take shape and I suspect the opening moments of this episode did a lot of legwork in laying the foundation for a potential twist.

"FBK, Two. NYPD, Zero."

While FBK’s screentime this week remains low, the chaos he causes at the top of the episode ends up setting the stage for some really unexpected developments in other corners of the story. It ends up being a beautifully choreographed domino effect that keeps all of the seemingly unrelated tracks moving forward at a steady pace.

For instance, Don Framt (AKA, the New York Ripper) shows up at the FBK crime scene and proceeds to taunt Detective Wallace from behind the police tape. The result is a heated confrontation that eventually leads to her removal from the Ripper case.

But more importantly, it prompts her to reveal the origins of her infatuation with ‘Stayin Alive’ by The Bee Gees; The song was playing on loop the night she discovered the body of one of his victims while responding to noise complaint.

FBK’s activities also send Harrison onto a path where he starts to understand what it means to get justice the right way (read: legal way); More specifically, the frustration that often comes with it. Given what he knows about his father, it puts him in a very interesting place. He isn’t strained by the burden of truth the way Deb or Harry was and instead finds himself growing to appreciate Dexter’s activities with the added context that his new job provides.

Perhaps most interestingly, Dexter finds himself on the opposite side of the fence when it comes to the NYPD and FBK.

It’s honestly something I never thought I would see on this show but I find it to be incredibly refreshing. Rather than seeing FBK as an obvious target, he seizes the opportunity to help Harrison, and by extension, the NYPD. Perhaps it’s easier when he already has several other targets lined up but I can’t help but feel his desire to be good dad actually outweighs his needs more often than not.

"Stayin’ Alive"

As an aside, I think it’s important to mention a supposed contradiction that some fans have pointed out following this episode. They suggest that some light hearted moments in season one (most notably, Claudette’s dance in the finale) seem to contradict the revelation that her obsession with the Bee Gees song is rooted in trauma; But I would offer a different assessment.

If you subscribe to the notion that Claudette might be Autistic (as I do), it would make sense that she doesn’t really attach feelings (positive or negative) of any kind to things like music. Instead, she forms intense connections with things that keep her focused on her goals; In this case, catching the Ripper. Hence, I did not take issue with the reveal.

"Its a little early to introduce you to my friends."

Dexter’s new found truce with Charley takes him into new territory when it comes time to spring their trap on the Sleepy-Eyed Stranger (Ray). In a brilliant twist on a familiar setup, their plan to lure and kill Ray using Prater’s club as a ruse takes a dramatic turn when he reveals the details of his intended share.


Rather than bringing a traditional trophy, Ray reveals that he transported a live victim to New York in order to provide the ultimate share for Prater: a front row seat for a kill.

It’s a shocking revelation and a welcome means of keeping Prater’s legacy alive and well after death. More than that though, it forces Dexter and Charley into a unique position and gives her a chance to gain a better understanding of Dexter and what separates him from the other killers that she has come across.

While we have obviously seen Dexter work with others in the past (Miguel, Lumen, Zach Hamilton, etc), the dynamic at play in this episode feels like something new. Given Charley’s sense of regret and need to make amends, seeing Dexter pivot for the sake of helping an innocent is an intriguing development to say the least.

The two spring into action and work together to prod Ray into leading him to his intended victim. It’s a flirtatious partnership that is fun to watch but it’s also undeniable that the two make an impressive team.

When they finally subdue Ray and secure his victim, Dexter manipulates Quinn into becoming the man’s savior. It’s a classic Dexter move and a brilliant culmination of an exciting sequence of events. With Ray on the table, Charley finally sees Dexter’s ritual in practice and learns a bit more about how he developed his sense of justice.

She even provides Dexter with some impressive insight into how he operates; Creating a real sense that the two could potentially learn a lot from each other.

Though she doesn’t stick around for the kill itself, you can tell it’s an eye-opening experience for Charley and maybe even the beginning of a positive shift in how she perceives him. I’m actually eager to see this partnership mature over the course of the season; A sentiment I didn’t really see coming at the end of episode two.

If you ask me, aside from being a thrilling episode in general, this shift in how I feel about Charley might actually be the episode’s greatest achievement.

"Justice needs a little help sometimes."

The trajectory of Harrison and Dexter’s relationship has been one of the most interesting arcs in all of Dexter (in my opinion).

Resurrection in particular has excelled at creating some truly touching moments for the pair and by extension, shaken up the formula in some pretty profound ways. For one of the greatest examples of this, look no further than closing moments of episode three.


While dumping a body in the harbor (aboard the ‘Slice of Life Too’!), Dexter takes a phone call from a frustrated Harrison and does something unbelievable: He shares a moment of complete transparency with his son. Despite their complicated history, they have finally reached a point in their relationship that both are completely at peace with.

It’s another example of a fundamental shift for the character and the series that I think plays a major role in keeping the magic alive after so many years.

As an invested fan, It’s reassuring to see that Harrison has started on his own path while still feeling close enough to Dexter to lean on him for advice. Similarly, seeing Dexter being open with someone without the need to lie or manipulate speaks volumes for the character’s growth. But it’s the mutual respect and understanding that comes from their dialogue that I think makes this moment so special.

Dexter reflects back on Harry’s choices and motivations in order to provide comfort to Harrison when he needs it most.

It reinforces that Resurrection is ultimately a series about legacy; More specifically, the kind of legacy a flawed character like Dexter can leave behind for his son. In this case, he manages to deepen their bond by making a poignant statement about the roles that they each play in the pursuit of justice. Honestly, I’ll be shocked if this doesn’t remain one of my favorite moments of the season when it’s all said and done.


‘Live Free and Die’ is the highlight of season two so far. It does a miraculous job of keeping all of the plates spinning while striking an impressive balance between the different eras of Dexter.

It’s chock full of moments that would feel right at home back in Miami while charging ahead with fun new character dynamics, mysteries to unravel, and touching human moments that I think serve as the heart of the series.

Of course, it also features a wonderfully realized kill scene that fans will eat up… basically, this episode has a little bit of everything and left me more excited than ever to see what comes next.

Score: 9.5 out of 10

Nick

Nick has been a contributor and review writer for Dexter Daily—the ultimate Dexter fan site—since 2021, as well as the longtime host of the weekly video game show 4Player Podcast.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post

Contact Form