Exploring Brian Moser’s Files in Dexter: Original Sin – Age Gap with Dexter and Surprising Insights Revealed

Brian Moser has officially been revealed as the NHI killer in Dexter: Original Sin.

Brian Moser is officially back in the Dexter franchise, and in Dexter: Original Sin, he’s making his presence felt in Miami with his first murders following his release from the mental hospital.

Fan Theories Confirmed in Dexter: Original Sin Episode 8

After weeks of speculation, the latest episode of Dexter: Original Sin, titled "Business and Pleasure", confirmed a major fan theory about Brian Moser. The speculation began in Episode 2, "Kid in a Candy Store", when a man (played by actor Roby Attal) with a strikingly similar outfit, facial features, and hairstyle to Brian—also known as "Biney"—was spotted in a restaurant where Dexter was waiting for his colleagues. The character, initially credited as "restaurant patron," asked if the seat next to Dexter was taken, hinting at an attempt to reconnect with his long-lost brother.

Fans immediately noticed the resemblance, igniting social media discussions speculating that he was, in fact, Brian Moser. It took six episodes to confirm the theory, and the reveal did not disappoint.

Theories and Speculation Leading Up to the Reveal

For six weeks, fans debated Brian’s true role in the storyline. Some speculated that he was the child kidnapper, while others believed he was behind the NHI (No Human Involved) murders. A minority of fans doubted that adult Brian had any involvement in the present-day events at all.

Episode 8 not only confirmed that the man at the restaurant was Brian Moser, but it also revealed that he is the NHI killer, finally answering some of the burning questions surrounding his character.

The Tampa Investigation Unveils the Truth

The big revelation occurred when Harry and Maria traveled to Tampa, Florida, searching for leads on a potential suspect. Their investigation led Harry to a Tampa police department, where he examined the archived records of psychiatrist Paul Petrie—who had been brutally murdered by none other than his patient, Brian Moser.


As Harry sifted through boxes of Petrie’s patient files, he stumbled upon a folder labeled "Moser, B." The familiar last name immediately caught his attention, and what he discovered inside was shocking.

Uncovering Brian Moser’s Psychiatric Records

Many fans likely paused the episode to examine the documents on screen. We’ve gathered the key details from Brian’s files below:


Harry is frustrated to learn that Brian has been discharged from Harbor Light Mental Hospital, as the documents state he no longer poses a threat to himself or others.

Brian Moser’s Date of Birth


According to a document from Harbor Light Mental Hospital, Brian was born on March 29, 1966, making him five years older than his biological brother, Dexter Morgan, who was born on February 1, 1971. However, another document listed his birthdate as July 19, 1966, raising some inconsistencies.

Brian’s Behavioral and Diagnosis History


Brian’s hospital records documented multiple assaults on staff, as well as threats, theft, and disorderly conduct. His diagnosis history included:

  • Personality disorder
  • Major depressive disorder
  • Avoidant, dependent, histrionic, narcissistic, compulsive, and paranoid traits

Brian’s Admission to the Mental Hospital


Records show that Brian was admitted to Harbor Light Mental Hospital on March 26, 1973, at the age of eight, following the traumatic shipping container incident. His symptoms, medications, and a high-risk classification were noted in his file.

Paul Petrie’s Notes on Brian Moser


Harry also discovered psychiatrist Paul Petrie’s notes on Brian. The documents revealed that Brian was deeply affected by his mother’s death and was aware of Harry and Laura’s affair despite being only eight years old at the time.

One chilling note stated:

"Harry and Doris only wanted to adopt Dexter and not Brian, which led to problems. Brian wanted to stay with Dexter. Dexter called Harry 'father.'"

Brian Moser’s Psychological Trauma at Age 21

A later psychiatric session with Brian at age 21 provided more insights into his mental state:

  • Trauma from witnessing his mother’s brutal murder.
  • Awareness of the cartel’s role in her death.
  • Recollections of the abduction, the shipping container massacre, and being trapped for three days with Dexter.
  • Brian comforting Dexter by chanting lines from The Three Little Pigs.
  • Simmering anger at the cartel and the world for what happened.

Read full notes below:

"Brian was traumatized watching his Mother's death, grappling with a whirlwind of emotions. Brian's recollection of events is as follows: After his mother was discovered, cartel members broke into their home and after a violent struggle, Brian, Dexter and Laura were abducted. Brian being aware of it all.

Eventually they were packed into shipping containers where Brian and Dexter were witness to 3 other people AND their mother Laura being hacked into pieces via chainsaw.

They were left alive locked in the container in the darkness of the container as well as the bodies and blood. It took 3 days for the police/Harry to find them.

Brian was comforting Dexter the whole time chanting lines from the "3 Little Pigs". 

Shock gave way to disbelief as he struggled to reconcile the image of her as a loving mom with the reality of her dangerous double life. Anger simmered just beneath the surface, directed at the cartel that took her from him and at a world he felt utterly unprepared to face."

Raul Martinez


Brian’s first NHI victim was Raul Martinez, whose murder became Dexter’s very first crime scene as a Miami Metro employee.

As it turns out, Martinez worked at Harbor Light Mental Hospital, where Brian was a patient. According to the report, seven years before Martinez’s murder—when Brian was 18—he assaulted Martinez after being accused of stealing medication.


There’s also a subtle Easter egg in the document below: in the top left corner, you’ll find "Room 103"—the same room number as the bloody scene Brian staged in Episode 110 of the original Dexter series.

Harry’s Guilt and the Aftermath

By the end of the scene, Harry is visibly disturbed. As he scrapes notes from the files, a deep sense of remorse and guilt washes over him, realizing the true extent of Brian’s suffering and what he became after being abandoned.

It will be interesting to see how the story between Harry and Brian unfolds in the upcoming final episode of Dexter: Original Sin Season 1. Will there be a confrontation between the two? And if so, how will it play out?

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post

Contact Form